Symbol of Expression: Desecration of the American Flag

Under the 1st Amendment of the US constitution American’s are allowed freedom of speech. The Supreme Court clarified this issue through several rulings concerning 1st amendment rights and the American flag. Desecrating, disrespecting, or damaging the US flag is considered a symbol of self-expression or speech. Despite the meaning and symbol the American flag represents, destroying the flag does not violate the law. Citizens cannot be punished for this as indicated by the US constitution. As a result, people who burn, damage, or destroy the US flag are protected by the 1st Amendment.

In Spence v Washington (1974) the appellant desecrated the American flag by designing a peace symbol over the stars and stripes. The flag was owned by the appellant, there was no demonstration or speech made, and the flag was not destroyed. Despite these facts, the court found that the State of Washington had, “impermissibly infringed protected expression”, (Spence v. Washington, 1974). The case makes a valid point defining flag desecration as a form of self-expression and is recognized as a symbol of speech. US v. O’Brien (1968) also upheld the 1st Amendment, citing that the law cannot “single out for special treatment persons engaged in protest”, (US v O’Brien, 1968). In this case, O’Brien burned his draft letter in protest of the Vietnam War. Although he was protected by the 1st Amendment, O’Brien was prosecuted for burning a government document. This letter was associated with military enlistment and held critical and useful information. Later, in US v Eichman (1990) the Supreme Court turned down Congress’s Flag Protection Act of 1989. Their reasoning for this was that, “the mere destruction or disfigurement of a symbol’s physical manifestation does not diminish or otherwise affect the symbol itself”, (US v Eichman, 1990). Although burning the flag may provoke emotional feelings, it is essentially harmless. It does not affect the government or what it represents. Congress then has no real justification to protect this symbol.

Advertisements

About Russia Robinson

I am an independent freelance writer and free thinker. I strive to use my writing talents to benefit the greater good of society, one word, one sentence, one page at a time. Originally from Richmond, California I attended San Francisco State University receiving a BA in English Creative Writing and American Literature in 2004. After this I attended post graduate studies in 2008 at Georgia’s Kennesaw State University in Technical Writing. With an academic background in English, I have spent more than 10 years’ helping young people succeed. This can be seen in my career background in education and mental health. I am a certifiable Language Arts teacher for the state of Georgia. I also worked in social services including juvenile mental health treatment services and counseling. As a result, I understand the diversity of problems people face in their everyday lives. With words put together like so, I promote equality and a healthy society for all people regardless of individual differences. Conducting research, writing articles, essays, and blogging, I push to educate others about various issues that affect people. I also do this creatively through short stories, poems, pictures, and a novel in progress. My hobbies and interest are reading and learning. I enjoy all things art and all things nature. From camping and astronomy to photography and cooking, I enjoy sighting seeing and socializing just as much as I enjoy curling in bed with a good book or binge watching TV.
This entry was posted in Law and Crime and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s